Death of the Duke of Monmouth

15 July 1685, Tower Hill, London.

Why was the Duke of Monmouth Executed?
James, Duke of Monmouth. b. Rotterdam April 9, 1649 d. London July 15, 1685
James, Duke of Monmouth

The death of the Duke of Monmouth took place on Tower Hill, on 15 July 1685. The Duke had been found guilty of High Treason by Parliament days after news of his landing at Lyme reached Whitehall.  At the same, a price of £5,000 was put on his head for his capture dead or alive.

Monmouth’s Rebellion against King James II ended with the defeat of his army at the Battle of Sedgemoor on 6 July 1685.

What was the Duke of Monmouth Escape Route?

At the end of the Battle of Sedgemoor, the rear guard of the defeated Whig Army was holding the road to Bridgwater. It was clear to the Duke of Monmouth land the other commanders that there was no option but to abandon the cause. With the agreement of the rear guard Major Wade, the Duke, Lord Grey and Colonel Brandt the Count of Horn his lifeguard rode north toward Bristol.

The three leaders elected to head south to the New Forest and ordered the Lifeguards to ride northwest. Later in the day, the three men rested in a cottage in Downside owned by Edward Strode.  Discarding their heavy armour and changing horse, the party continued south overnight with a guide named Richard Hollyday.  Travelling by night using country tracks they moved east of Shaftsbury and reached Woodyates Inn. This pub is now on the main road from Blandford to Salisbury, but in 1685 it was a quiet backwater. By now the horses were tired, so the fugitives dismounted and exchanged their fine clothes for more common apparel.  They then set out on foot and as the sun rose on the 7 July they rested near the village of Woodlands just four miles from Ringwood.

The Hunt for the Duke of Monmouth

With the news of Monmouth’s defeat spreading across the countryside, the £5000 reward money became an attractive proposition. The Government General the Earl of Feversham ordered the Militia to block the roads heading North, East and South from the battlefield of Sedgemoor. Lord Lumley with three troops of horse and four companies of Sussex Militia infantry was at Ringwood. While to the south of Monmouth’s position where the Yellowcoated Militia of Sir William Portman. On the night of the 6 July, these Militia officers posted scouts across the area and the following morning they sent out parties of soldiers with orders to stop everyone on the roads.

One of these squads stopped two men on the road near the village of Holt at 5 am on the morning of 7 July. The men were searched and questioned. It became clear that the men were lying and arrested them. The Militia had captured Richard Hollyday and Lord Grey. After this news, Lord Lumley and Sir William Portman moved the bulk of their into the area north of where Lord Grey had been captured.

The Militia started enquiring at every house and cottage in the area and this paid dividends. Near Woodlands a poor woman by the name of Amy Farrent told the soldiers about two men. She said that they had gone into a nearby overgrown field of Rye, Peas and Oats.  However, as dusk fell Monmouth had not been found. Lord Lumley ordered the foot soldiers to beat the ground. As they close the search area, two men run from the cover. The Militia soldier opened fire but missed. The fugitives dived for cover.

Monmouth found in Bean Field

With more Yellowcoated Militia arriving the area was placed under a strong guard. At dawn the following morning the search resumed and by 5 o’clock one of the men was captured. After a brisk interrogation, he confessed in a strong Dutch ascent to be Count Horn, and with Monmouth. Encouraged by the five-thousand pounds on the Duke’s head, the Militia started a close search of all the bushes and ditches nearby.  At about 7 o’clock, one Henry Parkin discovered the Duke hiding under some fern and bracken. Parkin called over two troopers from the Sussex Militia and they seized the Duke.

On July 9, the Militia officers searched Monmouth and he was found to have his George, forty gold guineas and four books. These were his Pocketbook, a list of the Government’s land and sea forces, a Manuscript on Fortifications, and a book on Military Art. Monmouth was then taken via Andover, Farnham to London. As he was already attained there would not be a trial.

Monmouth and his Uncle

It was clear to everyone, including the Duke of Monmouth that he would be executed. Unless he confessed his sins and rebuked his legitimate claim to the throne then his family would lose everything. Their home, money and possessions.  The Duke did the only thing that would save his children from poverty and keep his land and title alive, he dropped his claim to the crown and begged his Uncle for mercy. The Duke knew that King James II would never pardon him, but the act would pardon the family.

When was Monmouth executed?

In the early hours of July 15, 1685, a vast crowd gathered at Tower Hill, London. Many had travelled by the river so that by dawn the whole area was already overflowing with people. They had come to see the last act in the life of their beloved Jemmy, their Duke. They came from all walks of London life, from the Soho apprentices to lawyers, but they all loved the Duke of Monmouth.

By nine in the morning, the mood was becoming angry and tense. Fearing the worst, the officials surrounded the scaffold and lined the way from the tower with thick ranks of well-armed soldiers. In their red coats, they created a bloody ribbon through the masses. Then just before 10’o clock in the morning James, Duke of Monmouth came from the tower and stepped into the awaiting coach.

Monmouth Arrives at the Scaffold

Print of Monmouth’s Death

The crowd now pressed forwards to see their Duke, forcing the redcoats back as the coach progressed the short distance to Tower Hill. Anyone in the vast crowd who garnered bad feelings towards the Duke or swore abuse quickly found themselves roughly put down by the mob. After the coach reached the scaffold Monmouth stepped out with solemn grace and dignity. Monmouth’s execution was imminent.

Although he was shaken by the love of the crowd, as he walked toward the scaffold, Monmouth saluted the soldiers with a smile. Then he mounted the steps with a firm tread. Once more crowd pressed forwards onto the great number of soldiers that surrounded the scaffold. However, as the Duke mounted the platform the multitude fell into a sombre stillness and silence. This was only to be broken by the sound of soft weeping.

Duke of Monmouth’s Last Act of Defiance

Playing Card showing Monmouth Death

Monmouth spoke softly, ‘I shall say little, I come here, not to speak, but to die. I die a Protestant of the Church of England.’ Upon which the crowd shifted, and the weeping grew louder. One of the four Bishops interjected and said some words to Monmouth. Then, the Duke spoke of his love for his Lady Henrietta, but once again this bishop interrupted him. As the crowd could not hear what was being spoken, they become restless, and Monmouth spoke out ‘I do own that. I am sorry that it ever happened.’

It was now that the great body called out; ‘No!’ others treasonously cried out ‘One King!’ or ‘For Liberty!’ As the soldiers and officials began to look for the culprits, the mob around the scaffold closed ranks and pushed the guards back. The tension was broken when Monmouth knelt in prayer, and then one of the Bishops said, ‘Sir, do you not pray for the King with us?’ Upon which the Duke, paused for some time. After an internal struggle, the Duke simply exclaimed ‘Amen!’

Monmouth’s Final Words

Once more the Bishop implored him to speak to the crowd and soldiers. That the Duke must other words of obedience to King James, but Monmouth retorted ‘I will make no speeches’. Turning away, Monmouth called his servant over and put into the man’s hand a toothpick case. This was the last token of his love. ‘Give it,’ he said, ‘to that person.’

With this Monmouth turned to Mr Ketch, and said so all could hear, ‘Here are six guineas for you.’ He then felt the edge of the Axe. The Duke then continued, ‘Do not hack me as you did my Lord Russell. I have heard that you struck him three or four times. My servant will give you some more gold if you do the work well.’ To this Ketch replied, ‘My lord this Axe is sharp enough and heavy enough.’ In silence, Monmouth took off his coat and lay down, placing his head calmly upon the block. Everyone fell silent as Ketch raised the Axe. Then it fell striking a hard blow that could be heard over the silent crowd.

Death of the Duke of Monmouth

As a gasp came from the crowd, the Duke arose a little and looked scornfully at Mr Ketch, before putting his neck once more on the block. The axe then fell, again, and again. Still, Monmouth’s body lived. The mob watched with great yells of rage and disgust as the wretched Ketch flung down his axe. With a curse the executioner exclaimed ‘I cannot do it, for my heart fails me.’ To this, the sheriff called out, ‘Take up the axe, man!’

All this time the angry mob called out, ‘Fling him over the rails, we will save him!’ Shamefully, during all this chaos Monmouth was still alive, paralysed upon that scaffold. As the Duke’s body twitched, Ketch picked up the Axe once more, then sent it crashing down two more times.

Dutch Print Showing the Final Act

To the horror of all around, the dead Monmouth’s head remained at one with his body. The crowd turned viciously on the soldiers and pushed closer toward the body of the people’s Duke. With the blood flowing from his martyred body, the despicable Ketch was handed a knife by the sheriff. It was with this, that he finally cut the head free from its immortal being.

Not the End of the Fight for Liberty

The incensed mob called out ‘One King, King Monmouth, KILL his butcher!’ and they surged towards Monmouth’s corpse. As those closest to the scaffold dipped neckerchiefs into the royal blood, the soldiers had to push their way through the angry crowd. The Bishops, sheriff and Ketch were engulfed by a ring of guards, as the common men pushed, punched, or spat at them.

As rough justice, in his rush from the crime, Ketch never received his bounty from Monmouth. Finally, as the crowd dispersed, Monmouth’s bloody corpse and severed head were laid together in a coffin and covered with black velvet. The Duke was then buried under the communion table of St. Peter’s Chapel in the Tower. The Duke of Monmouth was dead, but the Fight for Liberty continued.

Three years later, the future King William III landed near Torbay with an invasion army. Like Monmouth, William’s motto was ‘For Liberty and Property’. While in his army were over 2,000 veterans from the 1685 campaign. By the end of 1688, King James II had been deposed and was in hiding in France. The new King’s first acts were to issue pardons to all those killed and deported by the tyrant King. The Whigs finally won.

This account is based on a more detailed description of the Duke of Monmouth’s campaign of 1685 available from Helion & Company in my books Fighting for Liberty and One King!

Social Image Copyright (c) Warwalks.com 2023